ST. CLAIRSVILLE, Ohio — November 5, 2026 — After eight days of testimony and approximately four hours of jury deliberations, Andrew Isaac Griffin has been found guilty on all counts in connection with the 2021 murders of Thomas and Angela Strussion in Belmont County.
The verdict was delivered Wednesday, November 4, bringing the trial phase of the case to a close more than five years after the couple was found shot to death inside their Belmont County home.
A Belmont County jury convicted Griffin of four counts of aggravated murder, each with a firearm specification, and one count of aggravated arson.
Two aggravated murder counts were connected to the death of Thomas Strussion, while the remaining two involved his wife, Angela.
The couple’s deaths in September 2021 led to a lengthy criminal investigation that eventually resulted in charges against Griffin.
Testimony Revealed Alleged Planning Before the Murders
Throughout the trial, prosecutors presented witness testimony and investigative evidence concerning the events surrounding the couple’s deaths.
One of the key witnesses was Brett Cole, a longtime friend of Griffin who is currently serving three life sentences in Illinois for unrelated sex crimes.
Cole testified that he had participated in planning the killing of Thomas Strussion. During his testimony, he described preparations that included obtaining a prepaid cellphone and using a rain suit secured with tape around the wrists.
According to Cole, Griffin later told him that he had shot both Thomas and Angela Strussion before setting their home on fire.
Cole also testified that Griffin believed Thomas Strussion was attempting to arrange for someone to kill him.
The witness received immunity from prosecution in the Strussion case in exchange for truthful testimony.
His statements were among the evidence jurors considered before reaching their verdict.
Jury Reaches Verdict After Four Hours
Following the presentation of evidence and arguments from both sides, the case was turned over to the jury.
Jurors deliberated for approximately four hours Wednesday before returning guilty verdicts on every count.
The convictions include four aggravated murder charges with firearm specifications, as well as aggravated arson related to the fire at the Strussions’ residence.
The verdict represents a major development in a case that has drawn considerable attention throughout Belmont County and the surrounding Ohio Valley.
Sentencing Scheduled for December 1
Belmont County Common Pleas Judge Chris Berhalter has scheduled Griffin’s sentencing hearing for Tuesday, December 1, 2026.
The court will determine Griffin’s sentence at that hearing.
The convictions involve serious felony offenses, and the firearm specifications could affect the penalties imposed.
With the jury’s decision now reached, the case moves into the sentencing phase.
For the families of Thomas and Angela Strussion, the verdict marks a significant step in a legal process that has continued for more than five years.
River News will continue following the case and provide updates following Griffin’s sentencing hearing on December 1.
Visit RiverNews.org for continuing coverage of this case and other breaking news throughout the Ohio Valley.


